Fiberglass Repair - Composite Repair
Composites have numerous advantages over conventional building materials, including ease and durability of repair. However, damaged parts are often replaced simply because many individuals lack the knowledge to repair them or are intimidated by the prospect of fixing them. Below, we'll provide a basic understanding of modern composite repair, and detail the steps and techniques for both structural and cosmetic repairs.
The techniques described will work for any fiberglass structure and many "advanced" composites of Kevlar® or carbon fiber. Please realize that specialized procedures beyond those described here may be necessary for certain parts. Manufacturers of structural parts often publish detailed repair information specific to their parts. The manufacturer's instructions supersede all other information and should be followed completely. Generally, manufacturer information is more specific and does not contradict the standard repair procedures as outlined here. When the suggestions in this pamphlet are well executed, strong repairs will result.
Once a few fundamentals are understood, most composite repairs can be completed successfully, further extending the life of the part. Start by reviewing the three main principles of composite repair.
1) Structural repair theory begins by recognizing the difference between a repair and the original piece.
All repairs are secondary bonds, so they rely upon the adhesive quality of the resin for their strength. When a part is initially fabricated, its resin cures, or bonds, chemically with the reinforcement as a single unit, regardless of the number or orientation of the plies. This is called the primary structure or bond, and it is the strongest form in which a part can exist. Once the part is damaged, all repairs become secondary bonds attached to the original primary structure. This means that the repair is only as strong as the adhesive used to make it. For this reason, an adhesive used to repair a part should be just as strong as the resin used to fabricate the part. In fact, resins with strong adhesive properties are sometimes used for repairs. However, this substitution should cautiously tested as to not change the performance of the part.
2) Increasing the surface area will increase the strength and the durability of the repair.
Since repairs depend upon adhesion to the primary structure, increasing the surface area of the bond line will increase the strength and longevity of the bond. This is usually done by taper or scarf sanding the area next to the damage so the void can be filled gradually. The size of the taper is expressed as a ratio comparing the depth of the repair to the width of the taper. Generally, the stronger or more critical the repair needs to be, the larger the taper ratio. An alternate method of increasing the bond surface is step sanding. This procedure defines the size of the inner repair, then removes a one-half inch per ply of the surrounding material while working toward the part surface. The repaired surface grows considerably and the fiber orientation is evident in each step.
3) Strive to duplicate the thickness, density, and ply orientation of the original laminate to maintain the functionality of the part.
In this case, more is not necessarily better—as a part becomes thicker, it automatically becomes stiffer, regardless of the material in use. Rather, carefully replace every ply that has been removed in the damaged area with an identical material in the same orientation. This ply-for-ply replacement approach will guarantee the structure can withstand the same loads as the original.
These principles of composite repair provide a foundation for understanding the sequences further explained in this article. Keep in mind that while they detail the steps for both general cosmetic and structural repair, certain applications may call for additional steps or a varied approach.
Structural Repair Sequence
1) Inspect the damage, identify the materials involved, and determine whether the part should be replaced or repaired.
Damage generally falls into four categories, but they may all apply to your repair if the impact was severe enough. Tears, holes or punctures, crushed cores, and delamination are the most common problems. To make reference quicker, use a marker to outline the boundary of the damage. Close inspection is necessary as the problem area often extends farther than can be easily detected visually. A coin tap test is an effective way to test the surrounding area. An audible difference is easy to detect between solid laminate and crushed material when tapped with the edge of a coin. Identification of the materials involved, especially the resin, can be more difficult. Begin by determining the type of fiber reinforcement used. This will often give clues as to the type of resin employed. Marine applications where chopped mat is most prevalent have probably employed general purpose polyester resin. Fabric-based auto and industrial parts are generally made with either polyester or epoxy resin , so epoxy would be the safe repair choice. Carbon fiber and Kevlar® parts can be repaired with either vinyl ester or epoxy resin. Consult the original manufacturer before attempting any repair to an aircraft. They can recommend the exact system to use.
Sheet molded compound, or SMC, is a new composite material being used in the automotive, industrial, and personal watercraft markets that presents unique repair problems. Recognizing SMC from other types of FRP composites is critical so the proper repair can be performed. Parts made with SMC are produced in compression molds, so they are smooth on both the inside and outside. That's the first clue to identifying them. Next, SMC parts do not have an outer gel coat, but are usually painted or color molded. When the paint is sanded off, the underlying surface has a marble appearance. Finally, when damaged SMC is sanded, short coarse fibers are exposed and a dryer powdery dust is produced. These hints will make it easier to identify SMC. SMC is a polyester-based material, but it cannot be repaired with polyester resin. This is due to the mold release agent that is present throughout the entire SMC part. Unlike conventionally molded parts where release agents are applied to the mold surface, SMC is compounded with them in the resin mix for quicker processing. This means that as the damage is sanded to prepare a good bonding surface, fresh mold release agent is exposed. Polyester resin products are not strong enough to adhere to this surface. SMC SHOULD ONLY BE REPAIRED USING EPOXY-BASED RESINS, FILLERS AND ADHESIVES. When painting, use only catalyzed type paint systems. Once the extent of the damage and the type of material used is known, determine if the part should be repaired or replaced. If the manufacturer's specifications are available, check whether the damaged area is too large to be repaired. If no information can be reviewed, make a quick estimate of the materials and labor time needed for the repair and compare the figure to the price of a new part. A savings of at least 50 percent is the typical cut-off point to warrant proceeding with the repair.
2) Remove the damaged material and prepare the area for bonding.
Try to identify the sequence and the orientation of the material as it is removed layer by layer. When a part is broken or crushed, it is difficult to realign the pieces because the frayed fibers tend to "hang up" on one another. Use a saw blade to cut the length of cracks or tears. This relieves the stress on solid laminates, which often return to their original shape with little force. Cored parts tend to pancake and mushroom, further complicating realignment. A router is excellent for removing damaged core material without disturbing intact face skins. Try to remove as little material as possible so the repair does not grow too large. However, solid laminate must be exposed for a good repair. Continue coin tapping and grinding until all the damaged material is removed. Finally, determine the density of the core so it can be replaced with the same material.
Next, support the part so nothing gets distorted during the repair process. This can be as simple as strips of 2-inch-wide masking tape, or as elaborate as a custom-made clamping fixture. Generally, high-performance parts require very precise support systems.
With the part supported, proceed to preparing the bonding surface by grinding a taper or steps around the damage. This is the critical step for functional repairs, but it is also the most overlooked and abused. If a taper is to be used, measure the depth of the valley and calculate how far the sanding must extend to achieve the desired ratio. Mark the outer edge of the taper using a marker, and begin sanding inward toward the valley. Be sure to remove material slowly so the taper progresses evenly. Write down the orientation and type of fabric used as each layer becomes exposed so it can be replaced in the same way.
When step sanding, the initial calculation becomes more precise. For example, assuming the damage is circular, two inches in diameter and there are five plies in the laminate, mark concentric circles expanding one-half inch per ply from the edge of the innermost circle. The final diameter of the prepared area will be seven inches. Begin sanding in the center until the deepest layer is exposed. Step out one-half inch and sand down to the second deepest layer and so on, until all five steps are prepared. A right angle grinder offers the best feel and control for this delicate procedure.
For personal safety and cleanliness, tape the hose of a shop vacuum to the work surface so dust can be removed while grinding is taking place. When the sanding is complete, the whole surface needs to be thoroughly cleaned. Vacuum any remaining dust and then wipe the surface with a solvent rag. Acetone is usually sufficient for removing oil, grease, dust, wax, or other contaminants which would interfere with repair adhesion.
3) Laminate the repair patch.
Begin this procedure by precutting the core replacement and the reinforcement plies that will fill the repair taper. Cut the core first to fill the deepest hole. Some core materials like Nomex® Honeycomb have their own orientation which needs to be aligned in the part. Be sure to check this. Consult the list that was made during the preparation process so that each reinforcement ply is cut to the proper orientation. Cut each ply so it fits precisely into the step that was prepared for it. Modern repairs are made ply-by-ply, so the smallest piece is intended to go into the bottom of the valley. Stack the reinforcements near where they will be used, with the first layer to be placed in the bonding area on top of the pile.
Mix the appropriate resin or adhesive system for the repair patch. Pre-weigh the reinforcement schedule and mix only the same weight of resin. This will keep the resin content within a reasonable 50:50 ratio.
Pre-wet the entire bonding area with resin, then begin saturating each ply of reinforcement before it is placed into its step. Work on a sheet of plastic so the fabric can be easily lifted from the table once it is ready. A flexible rubber squeegee is the best tool for spreading the resin evenly through the fabric and removing excess which may be present. Place the reinforcement into its spot on the repair, ensuring the proper orientation. Stop every few layers to compact the patch as much as possible. A squeegee or grooved roller works well for this. Continue stacking the repair plies until all the fabric that was removed has been replaced. A final cover layer is then added over the entire area.
Plan on compacting the final repair patch as densely as possible while the resin is curing. Vacuum bagging is the most uniform method, but squeegees, rollers, or other clamping pressure will work adequately. Follow the manufacturer's recommendations for curing the resin or adhesive. If a two-sided repair has been planned, preparation of the opposite side can begin once the first patch has cured.
4) Inspect the repair before putting the part back into service.
Use the coin tap method to inspect the cured repair. The entire structure should resonate the same solid sound. Non-destructive load testing can also be used for greater confidence. This consists of stressing the part up to its expected service limit but not beyond. If the part fails prematurely, it should be discarded. For more critical structures, a testing laboratory or specialized equipment may be necessary before sign-off. If all is well, proceed to the cosmetic repair sequence.
Cosmetic Repair Sequence
A part's outer cosmetic finish is designed to hide and protect the structural reinforcement below, as well as be aesthetically pleasing. It is this surface by which most people will judge the whole structure. Even slight damage like scratches and gouges will mar the finished appearance. Worse, these often create a direct path into the structural layers, causing even larger problems. Cosmetic blisters are a problem which, left untreated, can turn entire boat hulls into sponges. The cosmetic repair sequence is similar to the structural sequence, but filler or gel coat replaces any reinforcing material. Surface preparation is still the most important aspect of a long-lasting repair. Finish sanding and polishing are the only differences, but they make a good job look truly professional. Many fear tackling cosmetic work because they think it requires expensive spray equipment for satisfactory results. Equipment is important, but proper material selection will give better results.
1) Inspect the damage and remove any loose or unsupported surface material.
Inspection of cosmetic damage is just as important as it is with structural repairs. Gouges often leave undercut areas of unsupported gel coat which at first appear fine. Press on them with a blunt tool and they will easily crack away. Every such area must be identified so it can be prepared correctly in the next procedure. Use a marker to circle each spot that needs preparation. This is especially important on large blister repairs. Once dust is in the air, it can be difficult to see the surface.
Begin by taping off the area surrounding the damage. This will keep sanding scratches around the damaged area to a minimum. Next, wipe the surface with acetone and a clean rag to remove any wax, oil, or grease which might contaminate the repair. When this dries, chip out all the loose material with a knife, then use 40-grit sandpaper to bevel the edges to a taper. The scratches should reach down into the crack or hole for better bonding strength. Even thin cracks will have to be "opened up" before material can be added to fill them. Blisters will have to be completely exposed at this time. Also, be sure the remaining laminate is s lid and dry. Wipe down the surface one more time to remove dust and anything else which may disrupt adhesion.
3) Mix and apply the appropriate cosmetic filler material.
Shallow scratches can be directly filled with color matched gel coat. Be sure to match the gel coat to a sanded and polished portion of the original, not the overall faded color. The repair may stand out at first, but everything will fade to the same color in about a month. Use a small brush to dab in the gel coat. Be sure it is higher than the surrounding surface so it can be sanded flush. Spray a light coat of PVA over the repair for a tack-free, sandable cure.
Deeper gouges will require structural putty filler to replace the missing material before the gel coat is applied. Resin with 1/32 inch milled glass fibers makes an excellent structural putty. Use a squeegee to spread it into the bottom of the gouge. Keep this filler slightly below the surrounding surface if gel coat is the intended top coat. When painting, the filler can be level with the surface because paint adds little thickness. When filling hull blisters, be sure to use vinyl ester resin to make the milled glass putty. This will add extra corrosion protection to these weakened areas.
If the cosmetic repair is following a structural repair, it may be necessary to level the structural patch with the solid laminate. Both grinding and filling may be necessary to accomplish this. Grind all high spots until they are flush with the rest of the surface, unless this will compromise the structural strength of the patch. Use filler to level any low spots. If grinding cannot take place for structural reasons, fillers can be mildly added to smooth irregularities, but the patch will always be visible. On marine repairs, use the 1/32 inch milled glass putty filler described previously. Other structures can usually be filled with standard pre-made talc body filler unless otherwise specified. Continue adding filler and sanding until the surface is perfectly flush.
Epoxy repairs are quite stable once they are cured, but polyester repairs should be heated slightly before final finishing. The polyester resin in the repair patch and in standard body filler continues to shrink for some time when exposed to heat. When the repair is nearly finished, sit the project out in the sun for a few days or set up a heat lamp. If the lamp is used, don't put it too close for too long. The concept is to "force" the filler to shrink before it is sanded to the perfect contour. Then, go back and sand the patch to the exact final shape. The surface is then stabilized against future heat problems.
4) Mix and spray the color-matched top coat.
If gel coat is the intended top coat, it is necessary to mix the gel coat with Duratec Hi-Gloss Additive . The additive will allow a full surface cure, reduce orange-peel and later sanding. Below-the-waterline repairs on marine projects need to use a surfacing agent like PVA or wax to ensure a thorough cure. Wax is excellent on large, hard-to-reach areas, but it can cloud clear gel coats. PVA is the best for spot repairs where access is easy while the gel is still wet.
If paint is the top coat, a surfacing primer is worth applying underneath. The primer will hide the last fine irregularities and seal the patch. When working on polyester parts, Duratec Surfacing Primer is the best material for the task. It has a higher heat distortion temperature, which further protects already stabilized patches from shrinkage. Most paint systems will stick to cured epoxy, so apply the primer recommended for the paint that will be used.
Blistered boat hulls should be covered in a layer of Duratec Vinyl Ester Surfacing Primer for maximum protection against future water intrusion. Once the barrier of vinyl ester primer is in place and sanded, it can be covered with polyester gel coat , conventional anti-fouling bottom paint, or a polyurethane automobile finish if it is not left in the water for extended periods.
Gel coat will need to be finish sanded prior to final buffing. Use a hard rubber sanding block and 400-grit wet/dry paper to level the gel coat. Focus the sanding effort only on the high spots until everything is flush. Then, switch to a foam sanding pad and even finer paper for the perfect finish. Be sure to change water when the paper is changed so the dust particles from the coarser paper do not continue to cut the surface.
5) Polish the repair area to the desired luster.
The last step of a professional cosmetic repair is buffing and polishing. Our #1102 and #1103 Mold Polishes are perfect for both polyester and epoxy patches. Use only Step 2 #1103 when polishing out a paint finish, but gel coat needs both compounds. The fine scratches left by 600-1000 grit paper will quickly disappear with the Step 1 Polish. It will even help remove overspray and some of the halo left after performing spot repairs. The finer compound gives it the final shine!
Composites are gaining larger acceptance in all types of modern vehicles, structures, and recreational equipment. The more they are used, the more they will begin to fatigue and break. When the parts break they do not all have to be replaced. Following these procedures, anyone should feel confident enough to embark on simple repair projects. Even difficult tasks can be tackled by intermediates. This brochure is intended to get anyone started. Practice will truly make perfect, but follow these simple guidelines to get good results the first time!